how does tris use verbal irony on page 318

20 0 obj Dramatic irony includes three phases: Installation, when the audience is informed of something the character does not know. Remember, you can use verbal irony just like Linklater did to add sarcasm or nuance to your dialogue. 2. Lets break down an iconic example of socratic irony in film. It can be hard sometimes to tell if a statement is verbal irony or not. 3. If Caesar's greatness is buried with him then why talk about it? These worksheets have been specifically designed for use with any international curriculum. There was just that minor drawback of him having Lord Voldemort sticking out of the back of his head!, (Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix by J.K. Rowling). Therefore, its most common to find verbal irony examples in drama or dialogue. ;UsXfkLLWV##m:t4!o 6!T(@R e-pY!mpMOg^(qwo How does Tris use verbal irony on page 66. 1. flashcard sets. @;7e%9Wv 's/4Q].h^LnBYC+24mB}0o|n8U455S+~[Qu!xQZ#h%gz$6i= AwFVx-[*g!9{u/C d0v} B}v4@(lSJ'%T!zJdc #f23uxdY Like when Westley says, as you wish instead of I love you.. Answer: C is the correct answer. It is only used intentionally, meaning that someone cant accidentally be ironic. It is also a good example of verbal irony, specifically sarcasm. But, Marc Antony knows that he cannot act without the people. It is one of the most famous excerpts from the play. 4 0 obj /Pl1 25 0 R >> >> The flirtatious daughter-in-law of the ranch owner, known only as 'Curley's wife,' invites Lennie to feel the softness of her hair. Sign Me Up. The Question and Answer sections of our study guides are a great The use of verbal irony enhances the effect of what is being communicated in a manner that is creative and something that gets the reader . This type of irony is much less nefarious. Its not a perfect example of verbal irony, but it is a good example of how indirect dialogue can add depth to your work. What does Tris choose for her new tattoo? This is used throughout the play to make people laugh or surprise them when it goes in a complete different direction. Please continue to help us support the fight against dementia with Alzheimer's Research Charity. My teacher gave me a packet and I dont get what irony is. Were here to help. If the speaker isnt trying to be ironic, then they arent being. Her response is "Sure, it's not like we do anything important in this class.". Were in a golden age of TV writing and development. "I love it when you talk down to me, it really shows me how much you care" is a form of verbal irony because the literal and actual meanings of what is said are different. Verbal irony is used when a speaker says something that has a different literal meaning from its actual meaning. Lennie's name is ironic because Lennie is not 'small' at all. It relies on timing to achieve their effect. Poem Solutions Limited International House, 24 Holborn Viaduct,London, EC1A 2BN, United Kingdom. Yes, Macbeth is explicitly stating that he is planning to kill Banquo. The most tragic irony, however, is in how close George and Lennie come to achieving their dream. How does Tris use verbal irony on page 318? >> from USC and an M.A. 3 | Summary, Quotes & Theme, Lennie & George's Relationship in Of Mice and Men, Praxis English Language Arts: Content Knowledge (5038) Prep, SAT Subject Test Literature: Practice and Study Guide, Common Core ELA Grade 8 - Literature: Standards, College English Literature: Help and Review, 12th Grade English: Homeschool Curriculum, American Literature Syllabus Resource & Lesson Plans, Test for Admission into Catholic High Schools (TACHS): Practice & Study Guide, PARCC ELA - Grade 9: Test Prep & Practice, FSA - Grades 9-10 ELA: Test Prep & Practice, Hamlet by William Shakespeare Study Guide, Create an account to start this course today. https://poemanalysis.com/literary-device/verbal-irony/, Poems covered in the Educational Syllabus. Abstract. But. (Breakfast of Champions by Kurt Vonnegut). copyright 2003-2023 Study.com. Lets examine how writers use verbal irony in comedy first! I dont even know what you think I asked for, said Francine. Again?Well, it changes every day, you see, said Harry.. Steinbeck uses verbal irony, a technique in which words are not what they seem, and situational irony, where events do not turn out as expected, to explore the gritty reality of these two hardworking men. We're going to answer those questions by exploring how verbal irony can add depth and complexity to dialogue and, by extension, characters. In Beauty and the Beast, an animated Disney movie, Belle refuses to marry Gaston by saying I just dont deserve you!, Resources created by teaching professionals. flashcard sets. If the ironic statement comes too early or too late in the conversation, is not suited to the circumstances, or is spoken with incorrect tone, it will only serve to confuse the other person or may just be considered offensive. /x#,/d}?eh7)mg;kk4Df2/wBmw4A^#FkPHxAt~9'ozWnMtVWkJlNWz^>\ PK ! But what is understatement and overstatement? Join 51,000+ happy teachers and students who use our teaching worksheets and resources every day. You can use these worksheets as-is, or edit them using Google Slides to make them more specific to your own student ability levels and curriculum standards. Every single person that visits Poem Analysis has helped contribute, so thank you for your support. A student who goes to the restroom every day during class asks the teacher if he can go. This website helped me pass! We pride ourselves on being a safe website for both teachers and students. There is constant confusion over irony vs. sarcasm but hopefully you understand the difference now. Verbal irony occurs when the meaning of what someone says is different from what they actually mean. George and Lennie travel from job to job not because it's what they want, but because the climate of the Great Depression has given them no choice. This is where the whole concept of irony was born, named for a Greek character named Eiron who used wit disguised as ignorance to defeat his opponent. The following passage can be found in Shakespeares history play,Julius Caesar. With every one of Caesar's virtues that Marc Antony lists, he provides a counter view from Brutus, then seemingly defends Brutus. The Office certainly has a lot of verbal irony, but its not the only entertainment property known for it. In this article, we're going to define verbal irony; including the different ways it can be used in screenwriting. lessons in math, English, science, history, and more. He claims to not be an orator, but it's clear that he is exceptionally talented. endobj People are more complicated than any single statement can define. Stumpy Legs over here turned into an old lady overnight, says Christina. Writers use verbal irony when they want to point out contradictions and absurdities, make the reader laugh, make fun of a situation or a person, and reveal hypocrisies that others ignore. $ [Content_Types].xml ( MO@&Wz0M.C~dgJKZ23J#m,eEDi l Ft #6"w9:0t[E[?N1~piM Pir1/C4^C,_R&+Hd\CBwPV*h"|x0gV5iy$4V"e9BA)jT(y>vwv(SLqWUDXQw4S^ 0F"\gsldYdLuHc9>(hVD5{A7t PK ! The double entendre presented in the title is an example of verbal irony, playing on two distinct meanings of the word "game". Sarcasm is verbal irony with attitude the intention being to hurt or mock someone. resource to ask questions, find answers, and discussliterature. DJ=D[q#%Ob[{@qIjk%;'dBx~yD/o'uBf&r{iosNk(ZV3h/@}^*rN9hI >D)OqvU(NVIl+P_R2{D/V3A~_LJS2 0j(SI*>-$RC{cI9";5Mi[N J?#lrquf-c. One day he had a better idea. Note: Verbal irony is not lying. Irony types can vary within literature and there can be examples of more than one within a given work. This makes verbal irony unique as a subset of irony, as it is the only form of irony that is intentional. Jim uses verbal irony to convince Dwight that he is slowly turning into a vampireand it is one of the best pranks of the show. He treats them as peers, exciting them to action. William Shakespeare was known to use many types of irony in his plays. Read on for a more detailed definition of sarcasm, including more examples from movies and TV. if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[320,100],'literarydevices_com-box-4','ezslot_4',112,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-literarydevices_com-box-4-0');Many people use examples of verbal irony frequently in everyday communication. So this leads to the question: is the irony here that life seems always to snatch away George and Lennie's dreams just when they seem to be within reach? Last updated by savannah c #640059 on 4/19/2017 2:07 AM Divergent why are the abnegations chosen as political leaders? Two ways you can utilize verbal irony is through understatement and overstatement. A real rattlesnake looked like this: The Creator of the Universe had put a rattle on its tail. Verbal irony can be a powerful tool in writing dialogue. Which of the following statements is the best verbal irony definition?A. 1. It's a life of bowing to the rules of landowners and the often-tyrannical men who manage the ranches. He wants to put the senators, such as Brutus, on notice that he is aware of their betrayal. Generally, however, sarcasm is used to show foolishness on the part of the other person, and it often biting and/or harsh, and carries some intimation of contempt. Verbal irony is found in plays, speeches, and literature when someone says something that is sharply different from the reality of the situation. Or will the literal meaning just confuse things? He talks of the nobility of Brutus, even though he has no respect for the man. . ', he starts in one of the most remembered parts of the whole play. Get unlimited access to over 88,000 lessons. How does Tris use verbal irony . Try refreshing the page, or contact customer support. Describe the city of Chicago. erbal irony is the most common type of irony because its tied directly to language which we use every day. A small child does not flush the toilet, and the mother says, "I really appreciate when you flush the toilet! Your email address will not be published. Their greatest desire is simply a home of their own, a place to put down roots, and a bit of stability in a world that seems to be falling apart. How would you feel about making a decision that would determine your lifes course at the age of sixt. Yes, sarcasm is one of several types of verbal irony. Austens Pride and Prejudice is filled with wonderful ironic and witty statements. What were you doing under our windows, boy?Listening to the news, said Harry in a resigned voice.His aunt and uncle exchanged looks of outrage.Listening to the news! Verbal irony involves saying what you don't mean or the opposite of what is true.. you say one thing and mean another. Verbal irony refers to the use of vocabulary to describe something in a way that is other than it seems. << /Length 9 0 R /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Width 282 /Height 40 /Interpolate Answered by jill d #170087 5 years ago 5/24/2017 7:37 AM. So how can you break put from the pack and get your idea onto the small screen? In his speech, March Antony really has two different targets: senators and plebeians. Or are you a little. The world of George and Lennie is not a world of their making; it's not a world they want or dream of. Often, but not always, verbal irony is used with a sarcastic tone Verbal irony is often a comment that conveys a different meaning than what it may seem to be. Answers: 2. Lets define verbal irony then well work through some verbal irony examples. Verbal irony is the most common type of irony because its tied directly to language which we use every day. Have you ever looked back at the dreams you used to cherish as a child and were barely able to recognize that time in your life and the person you once were? Click the Edit button above to get started. For . 2. Verbal irony is also used romantically throughout Richard Linklaters How to Use a Mood Board Template FREE Download, The Ultimate Guide to Auditions [FREE Casting Sheet Template]. Suddenly, your tomorrow is far different than what you had dreamed today, just as George is one day putting together the down payment on their home; the next he's burying his best friend. Every time they seem about to rise above their desperate situation, the cold, stark truth of poverty brings them crashing back down to earth again. Ironythe clashing of intended meaning and word choiceis a common tool used in artistic works. "As for the scarlet letter, I wear it for the sake of its gold-thread" (166). Throughout the speech, Marc Antony repeats several times that Brutus is . Which faction would you select at your Choosing Ceremony? Exploitation, using the information to develop curiosity and an emotional response from the audience. Now suppose Person A says I LOVE when YOU do that! in a sarcastic tone, then we can say they were using sarcasm to emphasize how much they actually hate it. A classic overstatement example can be found in 101 Dalmatians when Rolley describes just how hungry he is. Irony in Julius Caesar: Examples & Analysis, Repetition in Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare | Quotes & Analysis, Anachronism in Julius Caesar by Shakespeare | Overview & Examples, Dramatic Irony in Julius Caesar: Example & Analysis, Marc Antony's Speech in Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare | Context & Analysis, Friendship in Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare | Examples & Analysis, Soliloquy in Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare | Examples & Analysis, Symbols in Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare | Examples & Analysis, Mark Antony in Julius Caesar: Character Analysis, Overview, Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare | Literary Devices & Examples, SAT Subject Test Literature: Practice and Study Guide, 9th Grade English: Homework Help Resource, High School World History: Tutoring Solution, 9th Grade English Curriculum Resource & Lesson Plans, Holt United States History: Online Textbook Help, Fairy Tales & Fables: Study Guide & Homework Help, Short Stories: Study Guide & Homework Help, The Short Stories of Oscar Wilde: Study Guide & Homework Help, History, Culture & People of the Americas, 10th Grade English: Homework Help Resource, GED Social Studies: Civics & Government, US History, Economics, Geography & World, Common Core ELA - Literature Grades 11-12: Standards, Create an account to start this course today. They have nearly enough money on hand to make the down payment on a piece of land. In literature, there are three different types of irony: situational irony, verbal irony and dramatic irony. Answers 2. Not affiliated with Harvard College. % - Description & Quotes, Of Mice and Men Chapter 5: Summary & Quotes, Who is Curley's Wife in Of Mice and Men? KidsKonnect uses a secure SSL connection to encrypt your data and we only work with trusted payment processors Stripe and PayPal. Three experiments assessed four variables that may affect verbal irony processing: people's expectations of events, event outcome, evaluations of outcome, and shared common ground. How has it changed? Often,but not always, verbal irony is used with asarcastic tone. You can look in the book for the answer. There must be some indication, however, that the speaker does not exactly mean what she or he says. Check out the hilarious clip below. The effects of irony vary depending on the situation and how the writer or speaker uses it. Were going to answer those questions by exploring how verbal irony can add depth and complexity to dialogue and, by extension, characters. I would definitely recommend Study.com to my colleagues. Often, but not always, verbal irony is used with a, . This comes down to the difference between literal and actual meaning. hzGrk%0$W=D74qlc$CsE*'2T3"a6or`F5;g:N6(5h8[!2^nGCvY-ZJTIo0pp Asked by Doritos i #451648. Terri Beth holds a PhD in English language and literature from the University of Tennessee, Knoxville. What do you think caused the change? The first thing we need to do is to define verbal irony. Dwayne mimicked her cruelly in a falsetto voice: I dont even know what you think I asked you for, he said. "Hw"w P^O;aY`GkxmPY[g Gino/"f3\TI SWY ig@X6_]7~ Whats more, Antony repeats the verbal irony several times: But Brutus says he was ambitious, / And Brutus is an honorable man. It is clear that Antony thinks Brutus to be anything but honorable after having a hand in Caesars murder. Its like a teacher waved a magic wand and did the work for me. Ironically, his tears of loss are what Marc Antony would hope grants him the ability to be even more powerful within the Roman World. He's a hulking beast of a man, one who can outwork a team of field hands and barely break a sweat. Lets check out the scene from the movie to see it in motion. from Chapman University in Film Studies. A talented writer can employ any number of literary devices in their work to create intrigue, or call attention to a character or action. [ 21 0 R 22 0 R 23 0 R 24 0 R ] Assignment Respond to all the questions following I Knew a W.docx, Samantha Green - Life of Pi Ch 24-29 Guided Reading, because he goes to community college Although we live in overcrowded conditions, Subscriptions and books Some vendors handle books and serials while some only, UMass students interested in entrepreneurship. what is verbal irony exactly and what are its different subtypes? In a sentence, verbal irony means that someone is attempting to pass judgment on a situation, person, idea, or draw a comparison between the same. The amount of cruelty can range from light-hearted joking to downright nasty. In doing so, he is trying to remind them of how Julius Caesar once sacrificed so much to help them, and in some way, he shames them, saying that they should be doing more to honor the man. These arent the only examples of understatement and overstatement though. Its important to note that verbal irony is not sarcasm. He looked about as pleasant and relaxed as a coiled rattlesnake now. Verbal irony is often a comment that conveys a different meaning than what it may seem to be. Repetition in Julius Caesar's Antony Speech, Psychological Research & Experimental Design, All Teacher Certification Test Prep Courses, Characters in Shakespeare's Julius Caesar, Brutus Quotes from Julius Caesar: Analysis, Cassius Quotes from Julius Caesar: Meaning & Analysis, Julius Caesar: Famous Quotes from Shakespeare's Play, Oh, Julius Caesar, Thou Art Mighty Yet: Meaning & Analysis, Julius Caesar Betrayal Quotes: Meaning & Analysis, Example of Soliloquy in Julius Caesar: Meaning & Analysis, Ambition Quotes in Julius Caesar: Meaning & Analysis, Beware The Ides Of March: Quote & Meaning, AP English Language: Homework Help Resource, Middle School World History: Homeschool Curriculum, Character of Brutus in Julius Caesar: Traits & Analysis, Character of Cassius in Julius Caesar: Traits & Analysis, Portia in Julius Caesar: Character Analysis & Quotes, Shakespeare's Julius Caesar: Character Analysis & Traits, Conspirators in Julius Caesar by Shakespeare, Working Scholars Bringing Tuition-Free College to the Community. If the speaker doesnt mean to be irony, then they arent using verbal irony. If you reference any of the content on this page on your own website, please use the code below to cite this page as the original source. An example of verbal irony is if someone comes home to a messy house and says, Wow, its clean in here. The literal and actual meanings are different. The most important thing to remember is that the words you write will have an impact on the reader. Check out the video below to hear educator Christopher Warner explain the term in his own words. Will all readers understand the reference or the actual meaning of a phrase? "I love it when you talk down to me, it really shows me how much you care" is a form of verbal irony because the literal and actual meanings of what is said are different. B. Harry: "Yes," said Harry stiffly. Verbal irony is often a comment that conveys a. different meaning than what it may seem to be. Popular Literary DevicesParableBalladAphorismParataxisSonnetAntanaclasisFoilSemanticZeugmaKenningHypophoraAnapestEpigraphBathosDeus Ex MachinaRepetitionPrologueHalf RhymePeriphrasisEllipsisForeshadowingOxymoronHaikuAntistropheEpiphanyJuxtapositionClimaxEpithetMetaphorMoodPathosDactylFableHomographEpistropheSarcasmMetonymyPoetic JusticeTropeStyleThemeAnadiplosisSituational IronyAposiopesisAlliterationRhymeStanzaNon SequiturAssonanceAnaphoraNaturalismEvidenceHyperboleProseComparisonConceitMonologueContrastPersonificationInversionClichConcessionLimerickExpositionUnderstatementAsyndetonDenouementDouble EntendreInnuendoRiddleAnalogyCatharsisVerbal IronyOmniscientSpondeeZoomorphismSimileNarrativeCadenceAppositiveSynecdochePathetic FallacyArgumentRefutationNemesisAtmosphereConnotationDictionOnomatopoeiaLitotesAllusionAnachronismSyntaxImageryAntithesisChiasmusIdiomSymbolismPunCouplet. To find out more, see our cookie policy. The most tragic irony in Of Mice and Men is how close Lennie and George get to fulfilling their dream before it is snatched away. The word irony comes from the Greek word (eirnea), which means dissimulation or feigned ignorance. All forms of irony, whether situational, dramatic, verbal, or otherwise, have an aspect of things appearing to be different than reality. This means that Lennie's physical strength is also an incredible liability, because he is incapable of understanding or controlling his own power. Verbal irony, as it is intentional on the part of the speaker, requires that the reader/listener understands the nuance of the statement. Watch the clip to hear the only animal that could satiate his hunger. E.g. And [the Death Eaters would] love to have me, said Harry sarcastically. endstream Import scripts. Answers: 1. I pray you, tell my lord and father, madam, I will not marry yet. Some of the most famous words from Julius Caesar, by William Shakespeare, are spoken in Act III, Scene 2 as Marc Antony, a loyal friend of Julius Caesar, eulogizes his lost mentor. His work-roughened hands crave nothing more than the feel of a puppy's velvet coat or the plush luxuriance of a rabbit's skin. 1. He shall not make me there a joyful bride. 1139 6iD_, |uZ^ty;!Y,}{C/h> PK ! stream What ARE Divergents? While many of Harry Potters most beloved quotes are examples of his sarcasm, especially saying something direct but in a contemptuous way, the above quote is an example of verbal irony. A Guide to Verbal Irony Use and Examples. To unlock this lesson you must be a Study.com Member. This is exactly what George Milton and Lennie Small, itinerant farmers in Depression-era California, experience in John Steinbeck's 1937 masterpiece Of Mice and Men. More books than SparkNotes. I do not have the text of Divergent here at home with me, but you're looking for an instance where Tris uses sarcasm. Sign Me Up, Editing resources is available exclusively for KidsKonnect Premium members.To edit this worksheet, click the button below to signup (it only takes a minute) and you'll be brought right back to this page to start editing! All rights reserved. Sarcasm is when verbal irony is applied in a pointed way to emphasize something. It helped me pass my exam and the test questions are very similar to the practice quizzes on Study.com. Lennie's name is ironic because Lennie is not 'small' at all. Wed be best pals if they didnt keep trying to do me in., Harry: Yes, said Harry stiffly.Professor Snape: Yes, sir.Harry: Theres no need to call me sir Professor., Umbridge: Potter, do something! He has taught various film courses to students from 7th grade to undergraduates. Sometimes I wonder about the Creator of the Universe. Copyright 1999 - 2023 GradeSaver LLC. I feel like its a lifeline. Asking students to create storyboards that depict each type of irony makes teaching these elements a breeze. To find out more, see our, Download the Verbal Irony Worksheets, Examples & Definition, Verbal Irony Worksheets, Examples & Definition: https://kidskonnect.com, Prefixes Worksheets, Examples & Definition. For example, if its 100 degrees outside and someone says, Its a little warm they are making an understatement. Fortunato has managed to anger a man with the name Montresor who has hatched a plan of revenge during a great carnival. KidsKonnect is a growing library of high-quality, printable worksheets for teachers and homeschoolers. All terms defined are created by a team of talented literary experts, to provide an in-depth look into literary terms and poetry, like no other. However, if the reader could gain a glimpse into Marc Antony's mind, it is very clear that he does not believe that. What is significant about this? Verbal and situational irony is used throughout John Steinbeck's classic novel, Of Mice and Men about the struggles of life during the Great Depression. How does Tris use verbal irony on page 66? Four throws a knife, and it nicks Tris's ear. Curley's wife is ironically that unexpected thing that pops up just at the last second to shatter all your plans. The difference between stable irony and unstable irony is an important part of deducing an authors voice. Asked by savanah r #560100. The Creator had also given it front teeth which were hypodermic syringes filled with deadly poison. Plus, get practice tests, quizzes, and personalized coaching to help you |;9" word/_rels/document.xml.rels ( MO0&V]5-Sht lessons in math, English, science, history, and more. Asked by izabella r #1208101. Here, Juliet is trying to speak to her mother about her feelings for Paris and Romeo. %Lu#UnL+ALmK J9_2H5; 9\|?8lw2:F~>wFj*'. George and Lennie's experiences demonstrate situational irony in that they are homeless men whose fondest dreams are to settle down in a home of their own. There are a few different types of verbal irony. Verbal irony can never be accidental. There are many sarcastic comments in J.K. Rowlings Harry Potter series, such as the following exchange between Harry and his aunt and uncle:if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,600],'literarydevices_com-medrectangle-4','ezslot_3',118,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-literarydevices_com-medrectangle-4-0'); Why were you lurking under our window?Yes yes, good point, Petunia! Irony is a literary device used to surprise readers and create interest, but there are several types of irony. Others say we can only interpret an authors voice based on the things they write. ANTONY: The noble BrutusHath told you Caesar was ambitious.If it were so, it was a grievous fault,And grievously hath Caesar answered it.Here, under leave of Brutus and the restFor Brutus is an honorable man;So are they all, all honorable menCome I to speak in Caesars funeral.He was my friend, faithful and just to me.But Brutus says he was ambitious,And Brutus is an honorable man. 11. Verbal irony most often takes the form either of overstatement or understatement, and can also include double entendre, hyperbole, rhetorical question, and sarcasm. Some sarcastic comments do indeed use verbal irony to prove a point. They intended the words to mean one thing, but they sound different. This solves his problem of obfuscating the truth in other letters to them. Thus, the repetition of this line highlights the verbal irony in the speech. true /ColorSpace 26 0 R /SMask 27 0 R /BitsPerComponent 8 /Filter /FlateDecode Verbal irony, while involving non-literal meaning of language, does not have to involve mockery or criticism. The three types of irony are dramatic, situational, verbal. It was his bad chemicals, of course, which were compelling him to look like that. We know Janis didnt just come up and start talking about crack. In fact, we know that Janis is in on the con with Cady. They asked for volunteers. He uses the following lines: Here, under leave of Brutus and the rest. For example: He was my friend, faithful and just to me: Another example of irony is found when Marc Antony says that, the good men do is often interred with their bones, then he proceeds to remind the masses of all the great things that Julius Caesar did for them. Both characters pretend to be something other than what they are: the eiron is not actually stupid, while the alazon is not actually capable. Unstable and stable irony are also important to consider.

how does tris use verbal irony on page 318 2023